chill out, whitey
August 31, 2005 by SusanaHow is it September already?! Peace to all my fellow NYE-baby Virgos, and peace to the pizzaguy at Papa Ceo’s on Spadina who asked me today — “are you from Mexico?” I really love conversations that start out that way.
By now, most blog-types that make blog-type rounds have already seen this and the varying reactions to it — including Jay Smooth’s take. While the defenders of the “Kill Whitie” parties focused on the race question (à la “some of my best friends are black”), Jay touched on something far deeper:
I’ve been saying for years that irony is now the last refuge of a coward. A singularly dishonest and deluded sort of coward who imagines his behavior a mark of courage, as he fearlessly refuses to take anything seriously.
But the true mark of courage is a willingness to engage the world, and your place in it, with honesty and sincerity. Those who lack that sort of courage will spend their lives looking for something to hide behind. This cowardice is the root of all hipster irony.
Nail, meet the hammer. I’ve been searching for words just like these to express my frustration with hipster irony — a sub-culture of thought that’s made calling someone “easily-offended” a heavy insult. Where being serious is a downer and everything is fair game for mockery and fun. Why? Because you’re privileged and have a right to that fun, that’s why!
The controversy surrounding the Fashion Cares show earlier this summer is something that immediately popped to mind when I first read about this. Remember? Remember the “Bollywood/Cowboy” shitstorm? Here’s a re-cap: some eyebrows were raised when Bollywood/Cowboy: East Meets Western was marketed as the theme for The AIDS Committee of Toronto’s annual fundraiser, Fashion Cares. Those raised eyebrows were told to chill out and stop raining on the glam parade.
“Pamela [Anderson, host] will have gold bangles, earrings, bindi and cowboy boots for the occasion. We’re excited about the Bollywood genre — it’s a trendy culture and very relevant. Our show will have a sequence from Bombay Dreams,” informs Philip Ing, director of Fashion Cares, a fundraiser for AIDS. “We love Bollywood’s colours, styles and dance sequences, it’s like a fantasy world. The show will be like a scene from a Hindi movie.”
Yeeees. Brown culture is trendy and very relevant, but brown people and their opinions… not so much. A group called the ASAP (Alliance for South Asian AIDS Prevention) issued a number of statements outlining their concerns with the chosen theme. They were upset with the lack of South Asian representation in the show, the exotization of their culture, and disrespectful portrayals of religious figures. All valid concerns, and seeing as the Fashion Cares people were appropriating select elements of a culture not their own, it only seemed fitting that they hear out these concerns. Right?
B then there was this. A couple of socio-political analysts of the Kill Whitie School of Thought got together to write this editorial in which they responded to the complaints made against Bollywood/Cowboy:
ASAP’s second point was about eroticization. We can’t immediately call to mind an erotic South Asian stereotype, but we’re sure one exists…
As for the flagrant use (by which we assume they mean misuse) of religious imagery: we live in a secular culture in which religious freedom exists alongside the freedom to refer to the son of one of our gods as Jeebus, and we see no reason to exclude Kali or anything else from similar treatment, in the full knowledge that some may, indeed, be offended.
No. We live in a multicultural society in which the many voices and beliefs of our residents are protected and respected. So even if your jaded, secular ass thinks it’s funny (in that ironic Vice Magazine way) to crack jokes about the Pope and Jeebus, you’d better wake the frig up and realize that this city’s rules do not revolve around you and your beliefs. An abridged version of the editorial, as well as a section of the Ironic White Hipster Mantra, might translate to: Chill out, darkies, stop bringin’ me down!
I probably wouldn’t get so worked up over garbage like this if it weren’t happening in cities such as Toronto or New York. These are giant metropoli steeped in decades of immigration and multiculturalism and mixing and mashing. This old messageboard thread on the topic of the Bollywood/Cowboy debacle, the awful eye editorial, and all the fresh, asinine responses to Jay’s post (“People are so easily offended. My advice is to relax. If white girls want a safe place to dance to rap music, then what’s the problem with that?”), all make me daspair.
Isn’t anyone paying attention anymore? Where is this arrogant laziness coming from? This sense of entitlement to mock and appropriate in a white privilege free-for-all?
There’s so much more I want to say about this, but I’m late for Jeff Chang. More later. Maybe.

